Pizza TodayMar 4, 2025
Inside Madison’s pizza kitchen
Pizza Today’s Pizza Destinations feature explores the family, the kitchen, and the specialty pies.
Madison Avenue Pizza
Awards & press.
Reader awards, original stories, and videos from inside our Dunedin pizzeria.
Creative Loafing Tampa Bay
Seven consecutive
Best Pizza wins.
Best of the Bay Readers’ Picks, every year from 2020 through 2026.
View the winning history2020202120222023202420252026
2026 · Best of the BayBest Philly CheesesteakReaders’ Pick winner2026 · Best of the BayBest Dunedin RestaurantReaders’ Pick winner
Madison on camera
The big pie.
The people behind it.
Watch professional eaters take on the 32-inch challenge, see the One Bite review, and hear Sean tell Madison’s story.
12:10JWEBBY CAN EAT · 2024
JWebby takes the team challenge solo
James Webb takes on Madison’s 32-inch team pizza challenge by himself.
Watch on YouTube
22:43Joel Hansen · 2024
Joel Hansen vs. the 32-inch pizza
Joel Hansen visits Madison to attempt the 32-inch “That’s What She Said” pizza challenge.
Watch on YouTube
10:21Randy Santel · 2021
Randy & Katina take on the big pie
Randy Santel and Katina Eats Kilos team up for Madison’s giant 32-inch pizza challenge.
Watch on YouTube
9:16Katina Eats Kilos · 2021
The challenge, through Katina’s eyes
Katina’s view of the 32-inch team pizza challenge with Randy Santel.
Watch on YouTube
4:25One Bite Pizza Reviews · 2024
Dave Portnoy’s One Bite review
Dave Portnoy visits Madison Avenue Pizza for a One Bite pizza review.
Watch on YouTube
32:05A Story About Pizza · 2025
Sean on the Pizza Story Podcast
Sean Ferraro talks about Madison’s family beginnings, scratch cooking and community.
Watch on YouTubeMore interviews & television stories
45:05Sauced & Uncensored · 2026
Sean on Sauced & Uncensored
Sean shares Madison’s beginnings, expansion, cheesesteaks and the impact of going viral.
Watch on YouTube
3:39FOX 13 Tampa Bay · 2021
The giant pie on FOX 13
FOX 13 visits Madison to cover its giant pizza and eating challenge.
Watch on YouTube
1:49Tampa Bay 28 · 2022
The Pizza Skiff on ABC Action News
Local news follows the Pizza Skiff delivering hot pies to Tampa Bay islands and sandbars.
Watch on YouTubeA few highlights
Madison in the press.
PMQ PizzaNov 4, 2025
Talking New York-style pizza
Sean joins five other pizza makers to discuss their approach to New York-style pizza.
Tampa Bay TimesMar 21, 2025
The Tampa Bay Times’ pizza picks
Madison is included in the newsroom’s 2025 collection of favorite Tampa Bay pizza spots.
Bar & RestaurantOct 28, 2025
The story behind our cheesesteak
Sean talks about researching Philadelphia cheesesteaks and developing Madison’s house-baked rolls.
Creative Loafing Tampa BayDec 28, 2021
Among Tampa Bay’s 50 best
Creative Loafing included Madison in its list of Tampa Bay’s 50 best restaurants of 2021.
The archive · 2019–2026
More of the story.
41 features, interviews, and news stories. Choose a year to explore the original coverage.
20262 stories
20258 stories
- Dinner DeeAs recipe: ‘Return of the Mac’ Burger Pizza
- Nailing New York-Style Pizza: Six Chefs Share Their Secrets (and Mouthwatering Pics)
- How To Track Trends & Make Them Work For Your Business
- Dough, Dreams, and Determination: The Madison Avenue Pizza Story
- Madison Avenue Pizza in Dunedin FL with Sean Ferraro | Episode 25
- Dunedin Cares works to help bridge a gap in growing community
- Tampa Bay’s best pizza, according to us
- Madison Avenue Pizza, Dunedin, Florida | Pizza Destinations
20245 stories
- Win Bragging Rights With These 4 Food Challenges In Tampa
- Here’s how Barstool boss Dave Portnoy ranked Tampa Bay pizza spots
- Barstool Pizza Review - Madison Avenue Pizza (Dunedin, FL)
- Barstool’s Dave Portnoy was in Tampa Bay doing ‘One Bite Pizza Reviews’
- Barstool’s Dave Portnoy made his way through Tampa Bay area giving pizza reviews
20236 stories
- Madison Avenue Pizza owners took a risk and followed their dream
- ‘Pizza Skiff Guy’ in Dunedin expands to catering island parties
- Dunedin’s Madison Avenue Pizza relaunches ‘Pizza Skiff’ delivery service this summer
- The Pizza Skiff is delivering hot pies to Tampa Bay beaches on a boat
- Why Pizza Is the Feel-Good Food That’s Good for You
- 5 Best Pinellas Pizzerias For Celebrating National Pizza Week
202211 stories
- Madison Avenue Pizza serves the biggest—and craziest—pizza in the Bay
- Sweetie Pies: Try These 4 Dessert Pizza Recipes!
- Ahoy, Pizza Man
- A Florida restaurant owner bought a boat to launch his side hustle selling $20 pizzas to swimmers and sunbathers in Tampa Bay
- Big Pizzas, Bigger Hearts
- Man delivers fresh pizza by boat to Tampa Bay islands, sandbars
- He’s a guy, selling pizza, from a boat. ‘Damn, I’m on to something.’
- Dunedin-based Pizza Skiff delivers fresh hot pies to islands and sandbars in Tampa Bay
- Dunedin restaurant claims to have largest pizza in Bay Area
- 25 essential Tampa Bay pizza spots everybody should try at least once
- A readers's guide to the best pizza in Tampa Bay
20217 stories
- Tampa Bay’s 50 best restaurants of 2021
- Get Your Hands On Madison Ave Pizza in Dunedin
- Tampa Bay’s largest pizza is found at Madison Avenue Pizza in Dunedin
- Pizza challenge: Danny and Deanna try to eat Tampa Bay’s biggest pie, at Madison Avenue Pizza
- Dunedin restaurant challenges guests to eat a nearly 3-foot pizza
- Is This 32-Inch One-Topping Titan the Largest Pizza in Tampa Bay?
- Dunedin pizza shop offering largest pie in Tampa Bay, along with eating challenge
Older articles reflect their publication dates. Pizza Skiff stories document an earlier chapter of Madison’s history.
Visit Madison
2660 Bayshore
Boulevard.
Dunedin, FL 34698
At Alternate 19 & Curlew, near Honeymoon Island.
Restaurant hours
| Sun, Mon, Wed & Thu | 11 am – 10 pm |
|---|---|
| Fri & Sat | 11 am – 11 pm |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Bringing a group?
Find large party reservations through Resy.
Find a tableDine in · Carryout · Delivery
Pizza by the slice until 4 pm.